Filter results

Results (279)

Sort by:

Select all Select all

Page 1

Plato’s Parmenides

Luc Brisson (ed.), Arnaud Macé (ed.), Olivier Renaut (ed.)

Series: International Plato Studies

Volume 41 2022

Results in this title

Alessio Santoro Eleatic training. The aim and uses of dialectic in Plato’s Parmenides and Aristotle’s Topics S. 201-208

„… Eleatic training. The aim and uses of dialectic in Plato’s Parmenides and Aristotle’s TopicsAlessio …” „… Eleatic training. The aim and uses of dialectic in Plato’s Parmenides and Aristotle’s Topics207exercise …” „… SantoroClare Hall, University of CambridgeThis paper analyses the “transitional” section of Plato’s Parmenides …”

Lidia Palumbo Il prologo come chiave di interpretazione del dialogo intero S. 33-40

„… Napoli Federico IIThe aim of this paper is to demonstrate that the Parmenides’ prologue has two levels of …” „… only seems, that Socrates is refuted by Parmenides and Zeno, who appear to prevail in the discussion of …” „… theory of forms.Plato, Zeno, Parmenides, prologue, PythodorusIntroduzioneIn questo testo vorrei mostrare …”

Mario Regali Parmenide e il cavallo di Ibico: l’immagine dell’eros senile per la dialettica (Prm. 136e-137c) S. 43-50

„… in the Parmenides is extremely relevant: on the paraphrase of his poetry Plato builds a pivotal scene …” „… which bears the greatest importance both for the characterization of Parmenides and for the articulation …” „… . Through the paraphrase of Ibycus’ poetry, Plato then builds for Parmenides the mask of the old master who …”

Filippo Forcignanò Anaxagoras in Plato’s Parmenides S. 91-100

„… conversation to say that he is in the company of “a stranger from Elea, one of the followers of Parmenides and …” „… shows.Plato, Anaxagoras, eponymy, participation, mereologyThe proem of the Parmenides: why …” „… this general framework, the Parmenides adds a fundamental piece to the puzzle of the critical …”

Nikos G. Charalabopoulos Road to Academy. The implicit protreptics of Plato’s Parmenides S. 25-32

„… Road to Academy. The implicit protreptics of Plato’s ParmenidesNikos G. CharalabopoulosUniversity …” „… of PatrasThe Parmenides features at least three oddities, three unique features nowhere else to be …” „… dropped. The third oddity is the content of the text when it turns dramatic. The bulk of the Parmenides …”

References S. 527-568

„… ’. Ancient Philosophy 28: 1-20.Granger, H. 2010. ‘Parmenides of Elea: Rationalist or dogmatist?’. Ancient …” „… Parmenides and the Early Reception of Eleatism: Epicharmus, Cratinus and Plato’. Méthexis 24: 135-175 …” „… : Loffredo Editore.Casertano, G. 2015. Da Parmenide di Elea al Parmenide di Platone. In Eleatica 2011, a cura …”

Antonino Spinelli Sind die Ideen wirklich unteilbar? Zur zweifachen Natur der platonischen Formen (Prm. 131a-e) S. 221-228

„… a-e)Antonino SpinelliUniversität TübingenIn the first part of the dialogue one of the aporias that Parmenides …” „… and of the presence of forms in sensible things, which are introduced by Parmenides, must be denied in …” „… Difference (Sophist and Parmenides), and finally as the feature that allows the participation of sensible …”

Francesco Ferro La dottrina eleatica dell’Uno-tutto nel primo λόγος di Zenone S. 75-82

„… leading representatives of the so-called Eleatic school, Parmenides and Zeno. At the beginning, Socrates …” „… that Zeno’s thesis conforms to the doctrine of the One-All (attributed in the dialogue to Parmenides …” „… l’importanza del confronto con l’Eleatismofin dalle battute iniziali. Nel Parmenide, Platone affronta il …”

Claudia Luchetti La Noesi nascosta. Sulla presenza della teoria platonica dellʼAnima nella γυμνασία del Parmenide (142a-144e, 155e-157b, 157b-159b) S. 401-408

„… background of the second part of the Parmenides and allow us to see the deep continuity with Platoʼs …” „… impossible without soul.soul, dianoia, nous, principle of movement and change, dialecticsNel Parmenide cʼè un …” „… . Nel Parmenide il maestro di Elea non sostiene un monismo atomistico, ma un monismo dialettico (cf …”

Roberto Granieri Riferimento, essere e partecipazione. Prm. 160b4-163b5 e il Sofista S. 409-422

„… paper examines the fifth deduction (160b4-163b5) of the second part of the Parmenides and its connection …” „… with the Sophist. I argue that, far from providing us with clear formulations of arguments and theses …” „… the ontology and the theory of predication of the Sophist: first, the ontological requirements of the …”

D. Gregory MacIsaac Plato’s Account of Eleaticism: A New Interpretation of Parmenides S. 67-74

„… Plato’s Account of Eleaticism: A New Interpretation of ParmenidesD. Gregory MacIsaacCarleton …” „… Plato’s serious presentation of the Eleatic position. He shows that Eleatics’s counterintuitive thesis …” „… part eliminates all Forms but the One. Parmenides, consequently, is not a reductio of Eleaticism, but a …”

Introduction S. 5-14

„… of Eleaticism: A New Interpretation of Parmenides 67D. Gregory MacIsaacLa dottrina eleatica …” „… Parmenides 142b1-144e7 193Georgia MouroutsouTable of contents10Eleatic training. The aim and uses of …” „… contentsIntroduction 5On the threshold of the Parmenides I.Poésie et poétique dialogique dans le prologue du Parménide …”

Jens Kristian Larsen On common forms and dialectical inquiry in Plato’ Parmenides S. 183-192

„… University of Science and Technology It is a matter of controversy what message Plato’s Parmenides is meant …” „… , i.e. Parmenides, Theaetetus, Sophist, and Statesman, inquired specifically into the “logic” of such …” „… summing up the problem concerning the knowability of what “we,” i.e. Parmenides and Socrates together …”

Sergio Di Girolamo Parmenides’ hypothesis behind Plato’s Parmenides: ‘all the things are collectively called ἓν ὄν’ (Sph. 242d6) S. 173-182

„… ; ἑαυτοῦ στερόμενον, 245c5). What the Eleatic Stranger must be attacking is Parmenides’ conception of τὸ …” „… to explain the philosophical meaning of what at Prm. 128d5-6 is presented as Parmenides’ hypothesis …” „… in the γυμνασία, which, from this point of view, are thematically connected to Parmenides’ hypothesis …”

I-Kai Jeng Nonbeing and the Final Four Deductions in Plato’s Parmenides S. 453-466

„… the other hand, makes the titular character of his Parmenides announce a method of philosophical …” „… certain current approaches to the second half of the Parmenides to motivate my approach. Based on a …” „… stage I carry out my reading of the final four deductions and show how key moves made by Parmenides …”

Mathilde Brémond Gorgias and Antilogic in Plato’s Parmenides S. 101-114

„… Parmenides as a refutation of Eleatic ontology.3 I intend to show that taking into consideration Plato’s …” „… refutation of Eleatism. On the one hand, the second part of the Parmenides itself contains many elements that …” „… non-political antilogic the discourse of the “Eleatic Palamedes”, i.e. Zeno (T7). In the Parmenides itself, Zeno …”

Mary-Louise Gill Exercise on Being: The ἀγών of Heraclitus and Parmenides S. 149-162

„… Parmenides*Mary-Louise GillBrown UniversityAt the end of the first part of Plato’s Parmenides, after Socrates has failed …” „… to rescue his theory of forms from objections, Parmenides urges him to get more philosophical …” „… ) or resting (as Parmenides thought)? That is the contest (ἀγών) of Heraclitus and Parmenides. I argue …”

Sandra Peterson Socrates Objects to Zeno at 128e-129a in Plato’s Parmenides S. 83-90

„… Socrates Objects to Zeno at 128e-129a in Plato’s Parmenides*Sandra PetersonUniversity of Minnesota …” „… , Twin CitiesThis essay newly defends the view that the youthful Socrates of Plato’s Parmenides at 128e …” „… . Zeno’s argument is in defense of Parmenides’ thesis that being is one. Socrates’ objection that I believe …”

Kezhou Liu The Problem of Separation in Plato’s Parmenides S. 287-296

„… The Problem of Separation in Plato’s ParmenidesKezhou LiuLudwig-Maximilians-Universität MünchenIn …” „… Part I of Plato’s Parmenides, Socrates introduces the theory of separately existing Forms, but this …” „… doctrine is severely attacked by Parmenides. In this paper I will argue firstly that Socrates’ thesis of …”

Julia Pfefferkorn Parmenides auf dem Prüfstand: Unendliche Schwierigkeiten und eine Aufgabe S. 51-58

„… Parmenides who, in the second half of his exercise, treads the very path which, according to the poem of the …” „… part of the Parmenides: it contains clear signs that warn the reader against considering the exercise …” „… exercise might really go back to parts of the historical Parmenides’ poem is scrutinised. The analysis …”

Claudia Mársico Intra-Socratic polemics. The Parmenides as an element of an anti-Megaric program S. 133-146

„… Parmenides. To analyse this point, we will dwell on the question of the impact of Eleatism on the Megaric …” „… , the Parmenides is an example of the collision between these contrasting receptions of eleatism, so …” „… Parmenides, which, viewed from this perspective, implies both the challenge of the Megaric eleatism that …”

Dougal Blyth Dialectic and Forms in Prm. 137c-144e S. 339-346

„… analysis of a sequence within the first and second deductions of Plato’s Parmenides is presented (rather …” „… consequent need, not satisfied in the Parmenides, for an account of how this is possible.dialectic, forms …” „… content of the terms attributed to them by ‘essential’ predication or ‘self-predication’.6Parmenides …”

Lloyd P. Gerson Plotinus and Parmenides S. 491-500

„… Plotinus and ParmenidesLloyd P. GersonUniversity of TorontoIn this paper, I consider and defend …” „… Plotinus’ interpretation of the second part of Plato’s Parmenides. According to this interpretation, the …” „… , Neoplatonism, ParmenidesIn 1939, F.M. Cornford published his book Plato and Parmenides.1 In the course of this …”

Michele Corradi Il Parmenide di Platone fra il Περὶ τοῦ μὴ ὄντος di Gorgia e il Περὶ τοῦ ὄντος di Protagora: l’ombra dei sofisti nella γυμνασία S. 115-122

„… arguments used against those who claim the unity of being, probably for the Parmenides. Where in the …” „… di PisaAs many commentators have highlighted, the reinterpretation of Eleatic theories is crucial in …” „… the development of many sophistic doctrines. Moreover, the sophistic interpretation of Eleatism plays …”

Irmgard Männlein-Robert Der ferne Gott – Ideen auf Distanz? Die siebte Aporie im Kontext (Prm. 133b4–135b4) S. 269-278

„… Männlein-RobertUniversität TübingenThe focus of this contribution is on the seventh Aporia of Parmenides, which is closely …” „… connected to the sixth. In the latter Parmenides had named the biggest problem: the recognizability of the …” „… ideas (Prm. 133b3 ss.). In the seventh Aporia he concentrates on the absolute separation, lack of …”

Ivan Adriano Licciardi Simplicio, in Cael. 556, 3-560, 10, a margine di Platone, Prm. 135b8-c1. Prolegomeni a una genealogia del parallelismo onto-epistemologico S. 517-526

„… , where Parmenides, turning towards Socrates, says that whoever denies the theory of ideas, that is the …” „… Parmenides a supporter of the onto-epistemological parallelism. In Simplicius’ opinion the historical …” „… philosophers that admitted the principle of the onto-epistemological parallelism.Parmenides, Plato, Aristotle …”

François Renaud Poésie et poétique dialogique dans le prologue du Parménide S. 17-24

„… I. On the threshold of the Parmenides Poésie et poétique dialogique dans le prologue du …” „… ParménideFrançois RenaudUniversité de Moncton, CanadaThe prologue of the Parmenides contains a three-level narrative …” „… (Cephalus, Antiphon, Pythodorus), the most complex narrative structure of the Platonic corpus. What can …”

Georgia Mouroutsou A Diagnosis of Dialectic in Parmenides 142b1-144e7 S. 193-200

„… A Diagnosis of Dialectic in Parmenides 142b1-144e7*Georgia MouroutsouKing’s University College at …” „… the above respect. (ii) Although the kind of beings that Parmenides alludes to go beyond numbers in …” „… of the Parmenides seems to be a διαπορεῖν, a working through difficulties,1 with an invitation to …”

Ivana Costa Las huellas de Gorgias y el robo del λόγος de Zenón S. 123-132

„… - ὑποτίθημι axis and the impact of Gorgias on the project of the Parmenides. Though Gorgias presence in our …” „… that links Gorgias’ particular understanding of Eleatic dialectics with appropriation on Plato’s part …” „… entre Zenón, Parménides y Sócrates, Platón ha querido poner en relación 1) la ontología de los eléatas …”

Noburu Notomi Homonymy and Similarity in Plato’s Parmenides S. 211-220

„… , particularly Eleatics, often use this word in the sense of ‘the same’. In his poem, Parmenides uses these two …” „… IV. The Theory of FormsHomonymy and Similarity in Plato’s ParmenidesNoburu NotomiThe University of …” „… . In Part 2 of the Parmenides, similarity is discussed as one feature to examine in relation to the One …”

Maurizio Migliori The many meanings of the One in Plato’s Parmenides S. 299-308

„… V. Hypothesis and deductionsThe many meanings of the One in Plato’s Parmenides …” „… . Finally, Plato proposes in the first two theses two different ideas of the One, making Parmenides’ scheme …” „… text, Migliori 2017a. On the Parmenides I wrote my first analysis of a dialectical dialogue, Migliori …”

Béatrice Lienemann Prädikationen pros heauto im Parmenides als Aussagen über die Struktur von Ideen S. 317-330

„… distinction between two types of predication in the Parmenides, i.e. (i) predications in relation to others …” „… Prädikationen pros heauto im Parmenides als Aussagen über die Struktur von IdeenBéatrice …” „… (pros ta alla) and (ii) predications in relation to the thing itself, i.e. to the subject of predication …”

Harold Tarrant Apuleian Evidence regarding Pre-Plotinian Interpretation of the Parmenides S. 483-490

„… Apuleian Evidence regarding Pre-Plotinian Interpretation of the ParmenidesHarold TarrantUniversity …” „… of Parmenides as describing a supreme god who is properly thought of as one and is marked by …” „… metaphysical interpretation of the Parmenides (henceforth Prm.) is best known from Plotinus, where it surfaces …”

Melina G. Mouzala Forms as paradigms in Plato’s Parmenides 132c-d. Proclus’ response to Aristotle and Alexander of Aphrodisias’ attacks on the Forms considered as patterns S. 501-508

„… Forms as paradigms in Plato’s Parmenides 132c-d. Proclus’ response to Aristotle and Alexander of …” „… Parmenides), by investigating Alexander of Aphrodisias’ exegesis of the Aristotelian objections. We will …” „… , Proclus, Parmenides, Forms, paradigmsAt the beginning of his comment on Prm. 132d (906.10-30),1 Proclus …”

doi.org/10.5771/9783985720217

No access

Select for citation download

Sein und Welt

Parmenides

2017

Results in this title

IV. Indices S. 204-230

„… .Loenen 1959 J. H. M. M. Loenen: Parmenides, Melissus, Gorgias.A Reinterpretation of Eleatic Philosophy …” „… Milets500 Xenophanes aus Kolophonca. 500 Parmenides495 – 445 Zenon von Elea494 Zerstörung von Milet …” „… Hieron wird Tyrann in Gelaca. 484 – nach 430 Herodot aus Halikarnass480 Parmenides soll Elea das …”

I. Historie S. 22-67

„… steht hier Parmenides?Parmenides ist für ihn »eine ausgezeichnete Figur« in der eleati-schen Schule.27 …” „… Lebenszeit des Parmenides fällt in die zweite Hälfte des 6. und die erstedes 5. Jahrhunderts. Elea, seine …” „… Sammlung über Leben und Mei-nungen berühmter Philosophen:55»Parmenides aus Elea, Sohn des Pyres, war ein …”

Alfred Dunshirn: Neuere Literatur zu Parmenides S. 231-256

„… Thesis of Parmenides. LasVegas: Parmenides Publishing 2004.Dieses Buch ist das dritte in einer Reihe …” „… und νοεῖν die Grundlagen von Parmenides’ »theory of knowl-edge« heraus. Bemerkenswert ist sein Hinweis …” „… des»Way of Seeming« (S. 140). Mit δόξα sei bei Parmenides ausschließ-lich die Meinung der Sterblichen …”

II. Text · Übersetzung S. 68-151

„… ‹ that Parmenides keeps using is syrinx. It had a very particularspread of meanings. Syrinx was the name …” „… before Par-menides used the term it was always to communicate a sense of nobil-ity. It was the kouros …” „… incongruous in the con-text of Parmenides’ argument. {…} So we should no longer hesitate tospell περ ὄντα …”

III. Kommentar S. 152-203

„… Persephone:»Parmenides has come down to the underworld, to the goddess wholives in the realms of the dead. The Greeks …” „… . Namen: B 8.53b. Sein und Schein9. Die Kosmologie des Parmenides: B 9–B 19a. Wahrheit und Unwahrheitb …” „… auch in ähnlichen Fällen für Parme-nides eine besondere Bewandtnis. Er übernimmt Momente der Tradi-tion …”

doi.org/10.5771/9783495818015

No access

Select for citation download

Platon - Anfang, Mitte und Ziel der Philosophie

Harald Seubert

2018

Results in this title

SECHSTES KAPITEL: FORM UND GRENZE DER DIALEKTIK S. 388-506

„… Verhältnis des Eleatismus u. a. H. F. Cherniss, Parmenides and the ›Par-menides‹ of Platon, in: American …” „… Reading of the Parmenides. Cambridge 2007. Siehe ferner diedifferenzierten Interpretationen bei F. von …” „… . Vgl. u. a. H. F. Cherniss, Parmenides and the Parme-nides of Plato, in: American Journal of Philology …”

SIEBTES KAPITEL: KOSMOS UND LEBENDIGKEIT – ›TIMAIOS‹ UND ›PHILEBOS‹ S. 507-623

„… Platon an den Einsichten des ›Vaters Parmenides‹vornimmt, dem er doch – wie sich etwa im ›Theaitetos …” „… , folgt dem Weg der »doppelköpfigen Sterb-lichen«, der die Doxa mit einbezieht und den Parmenides …” „… . Cornford, Plato’s Cosmology. The ›Timaeus‹ of Plato, translated with a run-ning commentary. London (1948 …”

VIERTES KAPITEL: IM STRUDEL DER SOPHISTEN – ›GORGIAS‹ UND ›PROTAGORAS‹ S. 167-207

„… Gegenredezu der Behauptung des Einen Seins, das allein sei, bei Parmenides.Gorgias sieht seine These im …” „… .), Gorgias von Leontinoi, Hamburg 1989.4 Dazu auch Voegelin, Order and History. Bd. 2, The World of Polis …” „… EarlyTheory of Knowledge, in: S. Everson (Hg.), Epistemology. Cambridge 1990, S. 60 ff.Sokrates weist einen …”

doi.org/10.5771/9783495813478

No access

Select for citation download

Plato’s Sophist

Luc Brisson (ed.), Edward C. Halper (ed.), Richard D. Parry (ed.)

Series: International Plato Studies

Volume 42 2024

Results in this title

Nestor-Luis Cordero The Stranger of the Sophist: A Citizen of Elea “Different” from the Eleatic Philosophers S. 173-182

„… Eleatic philosophical school? Ameinias, the first ‘master’ of Parménides (D.L. IX.21) was born in Elea and …” „… Elea, πόλις of the only two true Eleatics of the group, Parmenides and Zeno, since Xenophanes is from …” „… Parmenides. In fact, in spite of Theodorus’ presentation, the Stranger, albeit citizen of Elea, does not seem …”

Franco Trabattoni Platone confuta Parmenide, senza commettere parricidio. S. 211-218

„… , Parmenides is nevertheless refuted, because he does not realise that one cannot speak of non-being, even to …” „… intervento vorrei cercare di dimostrare che Parmenide è effettivamente confutato dallo Straniero di Elea, e …” „… logos che precede, ossia a quello degli oppositori di Parmenide, ‘but to Parmenides’ denial of the logos …”

References S. 543-566

„… , D. 1975. Plato. Phaedo. Oxford.Gallop, D. 1984. Fragments. Parmenides of Elea: a text and …” „… Parmenides 132b3-d4?’. In Plato’s Parmenides: Proceedings of the Fourth Symposium Platonicum Pragense, edited …” „… human raft. São Paulo. Braga da Silva, A. L. 2022. ‘The “Ideas as Thoughts” Hypothesis of Parmenides 132 …”

Raúl Gutiérrez Koinōnía, Dynamis y Justicia S. 283-290

„… . These ideas mentioned in the Republic are developed further in the Parmenides by replacing the model of …” „… agent, I suggest, leads Parmenides to propose a more fundamental form of koinōnia (Prm. 158d3-8), which …” „… koinōnia tōn eidōn nor the conception of being as a ‘dynamis tou paschein kai poieinʼ (Sph. 248c8) upon …”

Michele Corradi Sulla lotta e le altre τέχναι. Protagora nel Sofista S. 485-492

„… concerning the impossibility of falsehood developed by the Stranger of Elea at 236e-241d may have Protagoras …” „… response to Protagoras, it is possible to suppose that the sophist used arguments of Eleatic origin …” „… risposta alla posizione di Parmenide. E alla problematica eleatica può forse essere ricondotta la tesi …”

Noburu Notomi Similarities between the Sophist and the Philosopher S. 39-54

„… in Paris,8 I discussed and showed that the Parmenides examines the concept of similarity. When Zeno …” „… second part of the Parmenides, similarity is discussed extensively as one of the features to examine in …” „… relation to the One, and Parmenides gives the following definition of ‘similar’: τὸ ταὐτόν που πεπονθὸς …”

Claudia Gianturco Malum esse duplex, et le non ens ipsum: la distinzione tra τὸ μὴ ὄν e τὸ μηδαμῶς ὄν del Sofista di Platone nella soluzione procliana al problema del male S. 333-340

„… non-essere, invece l’altro, come dice lo Straniero di Elea (ut ait Eleates xenus), è ad un livello superiore …” „… – École Pratique des Hautes ÉtudesThis paper aims to show the centrality of the reception of the notion of …” „… relative non-being that can be derived from Plato’s Sophist for Proclus’ definition of the ontological …”

Rafael Ferber The Overt Argument Against Conceptualism in the Parmenides and the Covert Argument for Conceptualism in the Sophist (with a Particular Focus on the Being of Not-Being) S. 373-380

„… question of wether Plato would have interpreted Fragment 3 of Parmenides, to gar auto estin noein te kai …” „… ] But Parmenides, said Socrates, may it not be that each of these forms (eidê) is a thought (noêma), and …” „… ] Really! Then what about this, said Parmenides: in virtue of the necessity by which you say that the …”

G.R.F. Ferrari Plato’s Sophist: Rebarbative by Design? S. 135-142

„… Parmenides, despite having been a significant feature of the discussion in the first part. Furthermore, this …” „… contrast of topic is reflected in a contrast of dialectical method. In the second part, Parmenides uses …” „… the Parmenides recur in the Sophist and Statesman — dialogues led by another philosopher from Elea …”

Titelei/Inhaltsverzeichnis S. 1-14

„… where? 163Nestor-Luis CorderoThe Stranger of the Sophist: A Citizen of Elea “Different” from the Eleatic …” „… Francesco FerroParmenide padre superficiale e testardo. L’eredità eleatica nel Sofista. 219Florian MarionThe …” „… SophistSelected Papers of the irteenth Symposium PlatonicumInternational Plato StudiesPublished under the …”

Anna Motta L’eredità del Sofista nell’isagogica neoplatonica: le testimonianze di Giamblico e Proclo S. 535-542

„… MottaUniversità di Napoli “Federico II”The aim of this paper is to establish the importance of the dialectic of …” „… the Sophist not only for the creation of the Neoplatonist metaphysical system, but also for the …” „… metaphysical movements, then it is possible to assume that there is also a relationship between the division of …”

Claudia Marsico What is Wrong with Theaetetus’ Flight? Antisthenes and the Eleatic Hints in Plato’s Sophist S. 511-526

„… will underscore the Eleatic background, describing Antisthenes’ view as a reshaping of Parmenides …” „… exchanges. This article explores Antisthenes' episkepsis onomaton as a broadening of Parmenides …” „… classical Greek philosophy.9 It is worth noting that Plato presents the Stranger of Elea underlining his …”

Ronna Burger Socratic Philosophy on Trial: Plato’s Sophist and its Homeric Model S. 495-510

„… Being of the Philosopher and His ApparitionsIt is Theodorus’ introduction of his guest from Elea as a …” „… conduct “all-beautiful speeches” through questioning. Of course, in that “laborious game” (Parmenides 137b …” „… ’ evaluative inquiry. The Eleatic Stranger, like the Megarian and Pythagorean narrators of the Theaetetus and …”

Naoya Iwata What is the Process of Division for? S. 99-106

„… introduces to Socrates a visitor from Elea who is a friend of the followers of Parmenides and Zeno. Wondering …” „… , and others as sophists—Socrates asks the Visitor whether people in Elea think of sophists, statesmen …” „… means of questions? I was there once, in my youth, when Parmenides himself used the latter method, and …”

Julia Pfefferkorn Auf der Jagd nach einem Gestaltwandler: Zur Komposition des Sophistes S. 183-192

„… the Eleatic Stranger might be practicing a knowledge-based (i.e. ἱστορική, 267e2) imitation of the …” „… the Composition of the Sophist)Julia Pfefferkorn Universität TrierBy carefully analysing the opening …” „… of the Sophist, this paper argues against aporetic readings of the dialogue. First, I contend that …”

Maurizio Migliori To Act and to Suffer: Allusions to Plato’s Dialectical Metaphysics in the Sophist S. 291-306

„… MiglioriUniversity of MacerataThis paper considers the proposal made by the Stranger of Elea to materialists and …” „… >, we will necessarily have to test the speech of our father Parmenides and to force not-being in a …” „… textual datum is that they are Eleatizing, so much so that the Stranger from Elea claims to know them well …”

Index Nominum S. 567-570

„… , 482, 486Elea 25, 41-42, 72, 74-76, 100, 135, 163-164, 173-181, 183, 188, 190-191, 193-194, 196, 199 …” „… , 426, 447Palmer 221-222, 325-326, 328, 330-331Parmenides 39, 44-49, 55, 65-69, 100, 112, 121-122, 135 …” „… , 530-533, 535Philip of Opus 533Plutarch 366, 527-531, 533Polanski 463Polyphemus 60Proclus 47, 173, 333, 348 …”

Zdenek Lenner Erōs-Hunter in the Sophist: who chases whom, how and where? S. 163-172

„… order to solve the problem of the identity of the Stranger from Elea, by defining what kind of hunter he …” „… a “sophist”, to silence, and gives floor to a Stranger from Elea, who is “a comrade (ἑταῖρον) of the …” „… circle of Parmenides and Zeno, and a man very much a philosopher”6 according to the mathematician …”

Francesco Ferro Parmenide padre superficiale e testardo. L’eredità eleatica nel Sofista. S. 219-226

„… as in the Parmenides and the Theaetetus, Parmenides is considered a supporter of a doctrine that …” „… Parmenide padre superficiale e testardo. L’eredità eleatica nel Sofista. Francesco FerroPontificia …” „… , 31-95, 146, 207-220.Parmenide padre superficiale e testardo. L’eredità eleatica nel Sofista. 221Palmer …”

Mauro Bonazzi Of Dogs and Wolves, Fathers and Sons, Sophists and Philosophers S. 55-70

„… , the section of Parmenides’ patricide, with Aristophanes’ same words:eleatic stranger: Then, I’ve got …” „… contrasts with the treatment of the father Parmenides. The Eleatic Stranger adopts a very different stance …” „… Brandis). Likewise, in the Parmenides, Zeno compares Socrates’s critical attitude to the female dogs of …”

Béatrice Lienemann Self-Participation of Forms in Plato? An Analysis of Sophist 255e3-6 S. 433-442

„… provide an elegant response to the Third Man Arguments in the first part of the Parmenides. I will discuss …” „… rebut the Third Man Arguments (TMAs) in the first part of the Parmenides.First, I will briefly introduce …” „… in the extremely complex and controversial second part of the Parmenides. Furthermore, the second …”

John Palmer What completely is, what in no way is, and what is and is not in Plato’s Sophist and Republic S. 325-332

„… Parmenidean influence in their overall structure and in the set of distinctions they draw. Parmenides himself …” „… mutable objects of the wandering understanding mortals typically achieve. If the Eleatic Visitor is …” „… Sophist and Republic John PalmerUniversity of FloridaPlato’s treatment of what in no way is at Sophist 236 …”

Jenny K. Strandberg Finding Certainty in the Being of Non-Being: A Final Rejoinder to Protagoras S. 357-364

„… Parmenides’ illegitimate concept of Nothingness, as contrary to what is, the sophist argues that any …” „… : Complete Works (1997).357ing Non-Being in accordance with Parmenides’ illegitimate concept of Nothingness …” „… . And, so, they must enter the treacherous path of inquiry that Parmenides had warned against and …”

Lloyd P. Gerson Being and Power in Plato’s Sophist S. 265-272

„… connections between the two passages.Sophist, Republic, being, power, ousia, Parmenides, Idea of the Good1.In …” „… of Parmenides hangs over this dialogue. Parmenides is said to hold that “the all is one.”7 This leads …” „… ” no longer refers to “the all.” The internal complexity of Parmenides’ principle—being and oneness—is …”

Thomas Tuozzo The Eidos of Non-existence in Plato’s Sophist: 257a11-b4 S. 381-388

„… Tuozzo386of Parmenides’ interdiction. The continuation of the passage confirms the impression that …” „… spell of Eleaticism when it comes to non-existence: non-existence statements are unintelligible, and …” „… The Eidos of Non-existence in Plato’s Sophist: 257a11-b4 Thomas TuozzoUniversity of KansasSome …”

David J. Murphy Σκοπός and the Unity of the Sophist S. 365-372

„… in the Parmenides to “imitate” levels of being (in Prm. 1. 628.22‒25, 699.23‒26, 5. 1021‒1022 …” „… raised in the Parmenides, thus developing the metaphysics of the later Plato.Objections to my proposed …” „… . Not only his Eleatic origin but also memories about Parmenides make us think about Being and Not-Being …”

Jan Szaif Philosophical paideia in Plato’s Sophist S. 153-162

„… character of a personal examination since Parmenides is not present. (In fact, he is no longer alive at the …” „… University of California, DavisThe sixth division in Plato’s Sophist (226a-231b) describes a type of apparent …” „… , yet in pursuit of the therapeutic goal of dispelling the interlocutor’s illusion of knowledge that …”

Monique Dixsaut L’homme apprend, Théétète est-assis et Théétète vole. S. 469-484

„… I-Panthéon-SorbonneThe sophist finally takes shelter behind the inexistence of falsity: how could one say what is not …” „… since what is not is not? And even if nonbeing is just the other of being, when one says something other …” „… than what is, what is he talking about? Of his own image of the thing he’s speaking of. In what genus …”

Nicolas Zaks Why are Change and Stability Different from Difference and Sameness? A Reappraisal of Sophist 255a4-255b7 S. 417-424

„… the Eleatic Stranger, the main interlocutor of Plato’s Sophist (216a1-237a22). But producing …” „… difference nor sameness. Theaetetus. How so?Nicolas Zaks418Eleatic Stranger. Whatever we say in common of …” „… change and stability, this cannot be either of them.Theaetetus. Why?Eleatic Stranger. Change will be …”

Harold Tarrant The Place of the Sophist in Old Academic Theory and Curriculum S. 527-534

„… have entailed the inclusion of Parmenides as in the corresponding group in the Expositio, while the …” „… position of Xenocrates regarding Theaetetus is unclear. The respect afforded to Parmenides at 183e-184a, as …” „… authentic, i.e. the presence of cosmology or logic in the Pythagorean or Eleatic traditions, might easily …”

Alessandro Stavru How Socratic Is the “Noble Art of Sophistry”? Tracing the Gennaia Sophistike of the Sixth Diaeresis Back to Old Comedy S. 201-210

„… Eleatic philosopher Zeno in the Parmenides. The comic context of the passage of the Sophist suggests that …” „… the worse, in a series of five diaereses, the Eleatic Stranger concludes that the sophist has the …” „… sixth diaeresis of the Sophist, which clearly hints at a comic context. According to the Eleatic …”

Roberto Granieri The Referents of ‘Being’ in Plato’s Sophist S. 349-356

„… that of not-being (τὸ μὴ ὄν): false speech entails it; Parmenides banishes it. I will not, of course …” „… 8-c5 the Eleatic Stranger (ES) stresses that he and Theaetetus need to investigate the logos of what …” „… The Referents of ‘Being’ in Plato’s Sophist Roberto GranieriI argue that part of Plato’s strategy …”

Richard Patterson Knower and Known: The Making of a Sophistes S. 315-322

„… which the young, not-yet-philosophically mature, Socrates of the Parmenides denies separate Forms (such …” „… Knower and Known: The Making of a SophistesRichard PattersonEmory UniversityThe Eleatic Stranger’s …” „… Eleatic Stranger’s remarks reflecting a more full-blooded, Good-based version of Platonism than that which …”

François Renaud Socrate citateur d’Homère dans le prologue du Sophiste: considérations morales et elenchos S. 17-24

„… subordinate role: while in the prologue he proposes the subject of discussion and the Eleatic Stranger’s …” „… interlocutor, Theaetetus, he remains a mere listener for the rest of dialogue. How should we understand this …” „… to explaining it? In terms of the fictive, or dramatic, chronology, the Sophist is evidently linked …”

Lesley Brown Sixty-five years of the communion of kinds: a reappraisal of Ackrill’s ‘Plato and the Copula’ S. 401-416

„… ‘is’, a confusion he also found at points in the arguments of Part II of the Parmenides. In Robinson’s …” „… VI. KindsSixty-five years of the communion of kinds: a reappraisal of Ackrill’s ‘Plato and the …” „… Copula’ Lesley Brown, University of OxfordI offer a reappraisal of Ackrill’s classic 1957 article ‘Plato …”

doi.org/10.5771/9783495991367

Access

Select for citation download

Aristotle and the Eleatics

Richard McKirahan et al.

Series: Eleatica

Volume 9 2023

Results in this title

Titelei/Inhaltsverzeichnis S. 1-10

„… FrankAristotle and the EleaticsAristotele e gli EleatiEleatica, vol. 9Series editors:Massimo PulpitoStefania …” „… GiombiniSeries founder:Livio RossettiAristotle and the EleaticsAristotele e gli EleatiACADEMIAEleatica 9A cura …” „… ) .............................................................................................. 175 Metaphysics of an Instant: A Dialogue with McKirahan on his “Aristotelianizing Parmenides” (M …”

Introduzione Al limite della follia (GC 325a19). L’eleatismo attraverso Aristotele (M. Pulpito - B. Berruecos Frank) S. 11-42

„… ), 123-149. Curd, P. 1998, The Legacy of Parmenides. Eleatic Monism and Later Presocratic Thought, Princeton …” „… Parmenide di Elea, ha costituito uno snodo fondamentale e al tempo stesso eccezionale nello sviluppo del …” „… sodalizio umano e intellettuale i due pensatori di Elea, Parmenide e Zenone (esemplare in questo senso è la …”

Gli autori S. 237-240

„… veritas. Epítetos de la verdad en Parménides DK28 B1.29” (Archai 26, 2019), Review of David Sider …” „… Lafayette, Indiana, USA. È autrice di The Legacy of Parmenides (Princeton 1998; Las Vegas 2004) e di …” „… Philosophy of Mathematics from the Pythagoreans to Euclid. Ha pubblicato numerosi articoli su Parmenide e …”

Metaphysics of an Instant: A Dialogue with McKirahan on his “Aristotelianizing Parmenides” (M. Pulpito) S. 189-202

„… Metaphysics of an Instant: A Dialogue with McKirahan on his “Aristotelianizing Parmenides” Massimo …” „… Pulpito In his review of Scott Austin’s Parmenides: Being, Bounds, and Logic (1986), Jonathan Barnes wrote …” „… Parmenides, and I’d be surprised if any two of us agree completely”. RM seems to have, at first blush, a …”

Aristotle, Parmenides, Melissus (and Plato?) (P. Curd) S. 147-156

„… Eleatics) himself. So much for introduction. Richard’s proposal of an “Aristotelianizing” Parmenides is an …” „… the metaphysical tangles of Parmenides, Melissus, and Plato (the last Eleatic) were needed for …” „… Curd, P. 1998, The Legacy of Parmenides: Eleatic Monism and Later Presocratic Thought, Princeton (n.e …”

The relationship of Zeno and Parmenides according to Plato, Aristotle, and Eudemus. Reply to Richard McKirahan’s Lecture “Aristotle and Zeno” (B. M. Sattler) S. 203-216

„… study of Eleatism in the past years: (I) First, to make Parmenides not a numerical monist, but what is …” „… The relationship of Zeno and Parmenides according to Plato, Aristotle, and Eudemus. Reply to …” „… : according to Plato in his Par-menides dialogue, Zeno is a close companion of Parmenides and defends …”

aristotélisation de Parménide, est-elle un parménidicide? (N.-L. Cordero) S. 135-146

„… “to account for some of Parmenides’ views along lines which Aristotle took up over century later in …” „… Parmenides, and I’d be surprised if any two of us agree completely”, mais il pourrait y avoir une exception …” „… Parmenides’ Route of Mortal Opinions, saying ‘even Parmenides makes hot and cold principles, though he calls …”

Cortesía y estrategia discursiva. Menciones de Zenón en Aristóteles (A. Bernabé) S. 111-124

„… 1 Cf. McKirahan, 80, “He (Aristoteles) had invented logic and had a clear sense of what a successful …” „… proof was. He had also developed a range of concepts and associated distinctions that enabled him to …” „… de un plumazo el argumento de Zenón, en este caso incluyendo a Parménides: τοῖς μὲν γὰρ δοκεῖ ταὐτὸ …”

apparente contraddizione nel resoconto di Aristotele su Parmenide (L. Franchi) S. 157-174

„… plurality of sensibles and for how the sensibles appear to us, Parmenides posited two principles”22. Prima …” „… : http://journals.openedition.org/aitia/662 Bormann, K. 1979, “The interpretation of Parmenides by the Neoplatonist Simplicius”, The …” „… ”, Journal of Ancient Philosophy, 15, 1-17. 172 Leonardo Franchi Deichgräber, K. 1959, Parmenides‘ Auffahrt …”

Some Footnotes to Richard McKirahan’s Lectures at Eleatica XI (E. Volpe) S. 217-226

„… interpretation. 2. The presence of Parmenides in Aristotle’s corpus and his interpretation of Eleatic monism I …” „… to McKirahan’s interpretative proposal of Parmenides’ thought and to Parmenides’ presence in the …” „… but most important for my contribution is the new interpretation of Parmenides he provides, in the …”

lezioni Aristotle and the Eleatics (R. McKirahan) S. 43-110

„… This was the basis of the Parmenides chapter in the first edition of Philosophy Before Socrates (1994 …” „… ). A few years later Patricia Curd’s book The Legacy of Parmenides came out (1998).2 My initial …” „… . First of all I came over to Patricia’s side on the question what Parmenides means when he says that …”

Replies (R. McKirahan) S. 227-236

„… different interpretations of Parmeni-des. I especially value the way he bases his objections in the text of …” „… Parmenides’ fragments. I will discuss several of his points. 1. Dr. Pulpito is correct to say that …” „… suppose a presentist conception of being,” and perhaps this is what Parmenides does. We can of course …”

Some Remarks on Aristotle’s Interpretation of Melissus (M. Brémond) S. 125-134

„… his lack of charity: while Aristotle seemed to regard Parmenides and Zeno as thinkers that are worth …” „… question RM asks, i.e. why Aristotle chose Melissus rather than Parmenides as the main representative of …” „… and Parmenides as eristics in the Physics, that is as people who argue for the sake of winning a …”

Melissus on Limits and Beginnings. Reflections upon McKirahan’s Lecture on Aristotle’s Melissus (R. Güremen) S. 175-188

„… , however, that this line of defense comes at a price for Melissus. One major difference between Parmenides …” „… in the Parmenides. The following passage shows that this notion of generation has its own place in an …” „… 19 The ultimate evidence for the relevance of this notion of generation for Eleatism is to be found …”

doi.org/10.5771/9783985720903

No access

Select for citation download