Jump to content
A Comparative Study of the Formation of Contracts in Japanese, English, and German Law / Titelei/Inhaltsverzeichnis
A Comparative Study of the Formation of Contracts in Japanese, English, and German Law / Titelei/Inhaltsverzeichnis
Contents
Chapter
Expand
|
Collapse
Page
1–28
Titelei/Inhaltsverzeichnis
1–28
Details
29–31
A Note on Style, Transcriptions, and Translations
29–31
Details
Style
Details
Translations and Transcriptions of Foreign Language Terms
Details
32–41
A. Introduction
32–41
Details
I. Motivation, Subject, and Objectives of the Analysis
Details
II. Defining and Delimiting the Topic
Details
III. A Note on the Method
Details
42–309
B. Comparative Background
42–309
Details
I. Classification of the Legal Traditions of English and German Law and the Sources of their Contract Laws
Details
1. Classification of the Legal Traditions of English and German Law
Details
2. Sources of English and German (Contract) Law
Details
a. Sources of English (Contract) Law
Details
i. The Inter-relationship of the Sources in English (Contract) Law
Details
ii. English Legislation: Statutes and Statutory Instruments
Details
iii. English Case Law
Details
iv. EU Law: Legislation and Cases
Details
v. International Law
Details
b. Sources of German (Contract) Law
Details
i. The Inter-relationship of the Sources in German (Contract) Law
Details
ii. German Legislation: Gesetze and Verordnungen, German Statutes and Regulations
Details
iii. German Case Law: Rechtsprechung, German Court Decisions
Details
iv. EU Law: Legislation and Cases
Details
v. International Law: The CISG
Details
II. Contracts in English Law
Details
1. ‘Contract’ Defined
Details
2. The Historical Development of the English Law of Contract
Details
a. Contracts in the Kingdom of England in Tudor and Stuart Times: The Transition from Medieval to Modern Law Through the Action of Assumpsit and the Emergence of the Doctrine of Consideration (16th~17...
Details
i. Political and Social Background
Details
ii. The General Structure of Law
Details
iii. The Law of Contracts
Details
aa) Definition and Types of Contract
Details
bb) The Law of Contracts: Forms of Actions for Contractual Claims
Details
cc) The Formation of Contract and the Further Requirement of Giving Consideration
Details
dd) Contract Forms
Details
b. Contracts in the Kingdom of Great Britain and the United Kingdom in Hanoverian and Georgian Times: The Requirement of the Intention to Create Legal Relations and the Doctrine of Offer and Acceptanc...
Details
i. Political and Social Background
Details
ii. The General Structure of Law
Details
iii. The Law of Contracts
Details
aa) Definition of Contract
Details
bb) The Conclusion of Contracts: Emergence of the Doctrine of Offer and Acceptance and the Postal Rule
Details
cc) The Further Requirement of an Intention to Create Legal Relations
Details
c. The Subsequent Development of English Contract Law in Windsor Times (20th Century–)
Details
i. Overview of Political and Social Developments
Details
ii. Overview of (Contractual) Legal Developments
Details
3. Contracts in Current English Law and Legal Practice
Details
a. The Current Legal Background
Details
i. Basic Principles: Agreement Through Offer and Acceptance
Details
ii. Offer
Details
aa) ‘Offer’ Defined
Details
bb) Offers and Invitations to Treat
Details
cc) Certainty of Offer, Terms
Details
dd) Communication of Offers
Details
ee) Coming into Effect of Offers: The Mailbox Rule
Details
ff) Loss of Effect of Offers
Details
iii. Acceptance
Details
aa) ‘Acceptance’ Defined
Details
bb) Communication and Method of Acceptance
Details
cc) Coming into Effect of Acceptance: The Mailbox and Postal Rules
Details
dd) Loss of Effect of Acceptance
Details
iv. The Further Requirement of an Intention to Create a Binding Legal Relationship
Details
v. The Requirement of Consideration
Details
aa) ‘Consideration’ Defined
Details
bb) Rule 1: Sufficient Consideration, not Adequate
Details
cc) Nominal Consideration
Details
dd) Insufficient Consideration
Details
ee) Rule 2: No Past Consideration
Details
ff) Rule 3: Consideration of the Promisee
Details
b. Form Requirements in English Law
Details
i. Excursus: The Classification of Things in English Law
Details
ii. Written Forms: Standard Written Form and Evidence in Writing
Details
aa) The Requirements of Writing and of Evidence in Writing
Details
bb) Instances of the Written and the Written Evidence Forms
Details
iii. Special Instrument: Deed
Details
aa) Requirements of Deeds
Details
bb) Instances of Deeds
Details
iv. Signing and Sealing
Details
aa) ‘Signing’ and ‘Sealing’ Defined
Details
bb) Instances of Signing and Sealing
Details
v. Electronic Communication: Writing and Signatures
Details
aa) Electronic Documents: Writing
Details
bb) Electronic Signatures: English and EU Law
Details
c. Other Requirements under English Law
Details
i. Registration of Title to Land
Details
ii. Stamp Tax on Land Transactions
Details
d. Current Legal Practice in England
Details
4. Summary of Results
Details
III. Contracts in German Law
Details
1. ‘Vertrag’(Contract) Defined
Details
2. The Historical Development of the German Law of Contract
Details
a. Contracts in the Alte Reich (16th ~ 19th Century): Emergence of the First Great Private Law Codifications
Details
i. Political and Social Background
Details
ii. The General Structure of Law
Details
iii. The Law of Contracts: Gemeines Recht (Common Law) and the Allgemeines Landrecht für die Preußischen Staaten (General State Laws of the Prussian States)
Details
aa) Definition and Types of Contract
Details
bb) Contract Conclusion: Offer and Acceptance
Details
cc) The Coming into Effect of Declarations of Intentions
Details
dd) Contract Forms
Details
ee) The Further Requirement of Giving Arrha or Draufgabe (Earnest)
Details
b. Contracts in the Time from the Deutsche Bund to the Deutsche Reich: The Drafting of the BGB and of the HGB (19th Century)
Details
i. Political and Social Background
Details
ii. Structural Changes in the Law: Creation of an Imperial Supreme Court and the Codification of the BGB and the HGB
Details
iii. Contract Law in the Draft Legislation
Details
c. The Subsequent Development of German (Contract) Law (20th Century~)
Details
i. Overview of Political Developments
Details
ii. Overview of (Contractual) Legal Developments
Details
3. Contracts in Current German Law and Legal Practice
Details
a. The Current Legal Background
Details
i. Basic Principles: Contracts as Rechtsgeschäfte (Legal Transactions) and Willenserklärungen (Declarations of Intention)
Details
aa) ‘Willenserklärungen’ Defined
Details
bb) Types of Willenserklärungen and Methods of Declaration
Details
cc) Interpretation of Willenserklärungen
Details
dd) Rechtsgeschäfte (Legal Transactions)
Details
ii. Antrag or Angebot (Offer)
Details
aa) ‘Antrag’or ‘Angebot’ Defined
Details
bb) Angebot and Invitatio ad Offerendum (Invitation to Make an Offer)
Details
cc) Certainty of Angebote
Details
dd) Coming into Effect of Angebote: Empfangstheorie (Receipt Theory)
Details
ee) Bindingness and Loss of Effect of Angebote
Details
iii. Annahme (Acceptance)
Details
aa) ‘Annahme’ Defined
Details
bb) Method of Annahme
Details
cc) Certainty of Annahme
Details
dd) Coming Into Effect and Loss of Effect of Annahme
Details
iv. The Further Requirement of a Rechtsbindungswille (Intention of Legal Commitment)
Details
b. Form Requirements in German Law
Details
i. Excursus: The Classification of Things in German Law
Details
ii. Written Forms: Schriftform and Textform
Details
aa) The Requirements of the Urkunde
Details
bb) The Requirement of the lesbare Erklärung auf einem dauerhaften Datenträger
Details
cc) Instances of Written or Text Form
Details
iii. Special Forms Involving Public Authorities: Öffentliche Beglaubigung (Official Certification) and Notarielle Beurkundung (Notarial Authentication)
Details
aa) Excursus: Seals of Public Authorities
Details
bb) Unterschrifts- and Handzeichensbeglaubigung (Certification of Signatures and Marks)
Details
cc) Notarielle and Öffentliche Beurkundung (Notarial and Official Authentication)
Details
dd) Instances of Beglaubigungen and of Beurkundungen
Details
iv. Unterschreiben(Signing) and Siegeln (Sealing)
Details
aa) ‘Unterschrift’Defined
Details
bb) Characteristics of an Unterschrift
Details
cc) The Method of Unterschreiben
Details
v. Electronic Communication: Data, Documents and Signatures
Details
aa) ‘Electronic Contract’ and ‘Electronic Declarations of Intention’ Defined
Details
bb) Electronic Form and Electronic Signatures
Details
vi. Legal Consequences of Non-Fulfilment and Healing Methods
Details
aa) General Consequence of Non-Fulfilment: Voidness
Details
bb) Exceptional Instances of Other Consequences
Details
cc) Extent of Operation of Form Requirements and their Consequences
Details
dd) Healing and Other Ways of Avoiding the Consequences of Non-fulfilment
Details
c. Other Requirements under German Law
Details
i. Delivery and Registration of Property
Details
ii. Draufgabe(Earnest)
Details
d. Current Legal Practice in Germany
Details
4. Summary of Results
Details
310–435
C. Contracts in Japanese Law
310–435
Details
I. Classification of the Legal Tradition of Japanese Law and the Sources of its Contract Law
Details
1. Classification of the Legal Tradition of Japanese Law
Details
2. Sources of Japanese (Contract) Law
Details
a. The Inter-relationship of the Sources of Japanese (Contract) Law
Details
b. Japanese Legislation: Hōrei (法令), Japanese Laws and Regulations
Details
c. Japanese Case Law: Hanrei (判例), Japanese Court Decisions
Details
d. International Law: The CISG
Details
II. ‘Keiyaku’(契約, Contract) Defined
Details
III. The Historical Development of the Japanese Law of Contract
Details
1. Contracts in Japan’s Early Modern Period, the Tokugawa Era (17th ~ 19th Century): Legal Fragmentation in Peaceful Times of Growing Commerce, the Sowing Ground for Contract Law
Details
a. Political and Social Background
Details
b. The General Structure of Law
Details
c. The Law of Contracts
Details
i. Definition and Types of Contracts
Details
ii. Contract Law
Details
iii. Contract Forms
Details
iv. The Further Requirement of Giving Tetsuke (Earnest)
Details
2. Political and Legal Change during the Meiji Era: The Creation of the First Great Japanese Private Law Codifications (Turn of the 19th Century)
Details
a. Political and Social Background
Details
b. Initial Reform Projects in Japanese Private and Commercial Law
Details
c. First Codification Attempts and the Codification Dispute
Details
i. First Codification Attempt of a Civil Code
Details
ii. First Codification Attempt of a Commercial Code
Details
iii. The Codification Dispute
Details
d. The Creation of the Minpō (Civil Code) and of the Shōhō (Commercial Code)
Details
3. The Subsequent Development of Japanese Contract Law during the Taishō, Shōwa, and Heisei Eras (20th Century~)
Details
a. Overview of Political and Social Developments
Details
b. Overview of (Contractual) Legal Developments
Details
IV. Contracts in Current Japanese Law and Legal Practice
Details
1. The Current Legal Background
Details
a. Basic Principles: Contracts as Matching Ishi Hyōji (意思表示, Declarations of Intention)
Details
i. Contracts as Ishi Hyōji
Details
ii. Mōshikomi (申込み, Offer)
Details
aa) ‘Mōshikomi’Defined
Details
bb) Mōshikomi and Mōshikomi no Yūin(申込みの誘引, Invitation to Make an Offer)
Details
cc) Coming into Effect of Mōshikomi: Tōtatsu Shugi (到達主義, Arrival Rule)
Details
dd) Loss of Effect of Mōshikomi: The Distinction Between Taiwa-sha-kan (対話者間, Between Present Persons) and Kakuchi-sha-kan (隔地者間, Between Persons at Distance)
Details
iii. Shōdaku (承諾, Acceptance)
Details
aa) ‘Shōdaku’ Defined
Details
bb) Method of Shōdaku
Details
cc) Coming into Effect of Shōdaku: Hasshin Shugi (発信主義, Dispatch Rule) and Tōtatsu Shugi (到達主義, Arrival Rule)
Details
dd) Loss of Effect of Shōdaku
Details
b. Form Requirements in Japanese Law
Details
i. Excursus: The Classification of Mono (物, Things) in Japanese Law
Details
ii. Written Form: Writing and Shomen (書面, Document)
Details
aa) ‘Writing’ and ‘Document’ Defined
Details
bb) Instances of the Written Form
Details
iii. Shomei suru(署名する, Signing) and Ō’in suru (押印する, Sealing)
Details
aa) ‘Signing’ and ‘Sealing’ Defined
Details
bb) Instances of a Requirement to Sign and Seal
Details
cc) Excursus: The Different Types of Seals in Japan for Individuals
Details
iv. Contracts and Kōshō-nin (公証人, Japanese Notaries)
Details
aa) Drafting of Contract Documents by Japanese Notaries (Notarial Authentication)
Details
bb) Notarial Certification of Private Documents
Details
c. Other Requirements under Japanese law
Details
i. Registration of Property
Details
ii. Inshi-zei(印紙税, Stamp Tax)
Details
iii. Tetsuke(手付, Earnest Money)
Details
aa) ‘Tetsuke’Defined
Details
bb) Method of Effecting Tetsuke
Details
cc) Types and Functions of Tetsuke
Details
2. Legal Thinking and Current Legal Practice in Japan
Details
a. Japanese Legal Thinking Generally
Details
b. Contracts in Japanese Legal Thinking
Details
c. Contractual Formality in Japanese Legal Thinking
Details
d. Current Legal Practice in Japan
Details
V. The Modernisation of the Saiken-hō (債権法, Japanese Law of Obligations)
Details
1. Reasons Underlying the Reform Project of the Law of Obligations
Details
2. The Reform Process: Initiation, Intermediate Results, Coming into Effect of the Amendments
Details
3. Content of the Reform Project
Details
a. Concerning the Coming into Effect of Declarations of Intention
Details
i. Article 97 Minpō
Details
ii. Article 526 Minpō; Article 508 Shōhō
Details
iii. Article 4 Denshi keiyaku-hō
Details
b. Concerning the Time of the Formation of a Contract
Details
c. Concerning the Effectiveness of Declarations of Intention: Validity and Revocability
Details
i. Former Article 521, new Article 523 Minpō
Details
ii. Former Articles 522–523, new Article 524 Minpō; Article 508 Shōhō
Details
iii. Former Article 524, new Article 525 Minpō; Article 507 Shōhō
Details
d. Concerning Formalities of Contracts
Details
i. New Article 522 Minpō
Details
ii. New Article 587-2 Minpō
Details
iii. Article 557 Minpō; Article 39 Paragraph 2 Takuchi-gyō-hō
Details
VI. Summary of Results
Details
436–516
D. Comparative Analysis of the Rules on the Formation of Contracts in Japanese, English, and German Law
436–516
Details
I. The Concept and Types of Contract
Details
II. The Three Pillars of the Formation of Contracts and Indicia of Seriousness
Details
1. Offer
Details
a. Differentiation Between Offers and other Statements or Acts
Details
i. Statements and Acts Deemed as Offers
Details
ii. Statements and Acts Deemed as Invitations to Make an Offer
Details
b. Requirements for Offers: Certainty and Communication
Details
c. The Effectiveness of Offers
Details
2. Acceptance
Details
a. Acceptance and other Acts or Statements; Method of Acceptance
Details
b. Requirements for Acceptance: Unconditionality, Congruence, and Communication
Details
c. The Effectiveness of Acceptance
Details
i. Coming into Effect of Acceptance
Details
ii. Loss of Effect of Acceptance
Details
3. Intention to be Legally Bound
Details
4. Indiciaof Seriousness
Details
III. The Form Requirements
Details
1. Written Forms and (Notarial) Deeds
Details
a. Simple Written Forms: Evidence in Writing and the Textform
Details
b. The Standard Written Form
Details
c. Special Instruments: (Notarial) Deeds
Details
i. Requirements of (Notarial) Deeds
Details
ii. Instances of (Notarial) Deeds
Details
2. Seals, Signatures, and Other Forms of Signing
Details
a. Signatures
Details
b. Seals
Details
i. The Use of Seals in England, Germany, and Japan until Modern Times (19th Century)
Details
aa) Types and Functions of Seals
Details
bb) Sealing in Contracting
Details
cc) The Accessibility of Seals
Details
dd) The Development of the Sealing Practice
Details
ii. Today’s Use of Seals in England, Germany, and Japan
Details
aa) Seals in England and Germany
Details
bb) Seals in Japan
Details
c. Excursus: Other Forms of Authenticating Documents
Details
IV. Contracts in the Digital Economy: Online Transactions and Beyond
Details
1. Declarations of Intention and Formation of Contracts in Online Transactions
Details
a. The Classification of Statements made Electronically as Legally (Ir)relevant
Details
b. Coming into Effect of Electronic Declarations of Intention
Details
2. Contractual Form and Methods of Authentication in Online Transactions
Details
a. Electronic Contract Forms
Details
b. Electronic Forms of Authentication: Electronic Signatures and Seals
Details
3. Excursus: The Future of Contracting in Online Transactions through Legal Tech and Smart Contracts
Details
V. The Formation of a Sales Contract Concerning Real Estate
Details
1. The Classification of Real Estate in Terms of Property
Details
2. The Course of a Real Estate Transaction in Practice
Details
3. The Legal Requirements for a Contract Concerning Real Estate
Details
4. The Professional Parties Involved in a Real Estate Transaction
Details
a. The Role of Solicitors, Rechtsanwälte, and Bengo-shi (弁護士)
Details
b. The Role of Notaries Public, Notare, and Kōshō-nin (公証人)
Details
c. The Role of Real Estate Agents, Immobilienmakler, and Fudō-san-ya (不動産屋)
Details
d. The Role of Shihō shoshi (司法書士, Judicial Scriveners)
Details
517–574
E. Results of the Comparative Analysis Contrasted and Final Conclusions
517–574
Details
I. Results of the Comparative Analysis Juxtaposed with the International Perspective: The CISG
Details
1. The Sphere of Application of the CISG: International Sale of Goods
Details
2. The Formation of Contract under the CISG: Offer and Acceptance, no Form
Details
a. Offers
Details
i. ‘Offer’ Defined and Distinction from Invitations to Make an Offer
Details
ii. Requirements of Offers: Certainty of Terms and Intention
Details
b. Acceptance
Details
i. ‘Acceptance’ Defined; Distinction from Other Acts and Statements
Details
ii. Method of Acceptance
Details
iii. Congruence Between Offer and Acceptance
Details
c. The Effectiveness of Declarations of Intention
Details
i. Coming into Effect of Declarations of Intention
Details
aa) Coming into Effect of Offers to the Public
Details
bb) Coming into Effect of Acceptance: Must be Made Within a Set or Reasonable Period; Late Acceptance
Details
cc) ‘Reaching’ Defined
Details
ii. Loss of Effect of Declarations of Intention
Details
d. No Form Requirements
Details
3. Summary of Results
Details
II. Results of the Comparative Analysis Juxtaposed with the European Legal-political Perspective: The DCFR, the CESL, and the PECL
Details
1. The Sphere of Application of the CESL, the DCFR, and the PECL
Details
2. The Formation of Contracts under the CESL, the DCFR, and the PECL
Details
a. ‘Contract’ Defined
Details
b. Offers
Details
c. Acceptance
Details
d. Effectiveness of Declarations of Intention
Details
i. Coming into Effect of Declarations of Intention
Details
ii. Loss of Effect of Declarations of Intention
Details
e. The Sufficiency of the Agreement: Certainty or Determinability
Details
f. The Requirement of an Intention to be Legally Bound
Details
g. Form Requirements
Details
i. The Standard Written Form and the Textual Form
Details
ii. Instances of Form Requirements
Details
3. Summary of Results
Details
III. Synthesis of the Comparative Analysis and Final Conclusions
Details
575–611
Bibliography
575–611
Details
Literature in Print
Details
Online Resources: Blog Entries and Websites
Details
Personal Interviews, Lectures, and Seminars
Details
612–618
Table of Legislation
612–618
Details
International Conventions
Details
European Union
Details
England
Details
Germany
Details
Japan
Details
619–626
Table of Cases
619–626
Details
European Union (Court of Justice of the European Union; in chronological order)
Details
England (alphabetical order)
Details
Germany (by court in chronological order)
Details
Federal Consitutional Court (Bundesverfassungsgericht, 1951–)
Details
Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof, 1950–)
Details
Federal Labour Court (Bundesarbeitsgericht, 1954–)
Details
Higher Regional Courts (Oberlandesgerichte)
Details
Regional Courts (Landgerichte)
Details
Local Courts (Amtsgerichte)
Details
Imperial Court (Reichsgericht, 1879–1945)
Details
Other German Courts
Details
Japan (by court in chronological order)
Details
Great Court of Judicature (Dai-shin'i, 大審院, 1875–1947)
Details
Japanese Supreme Court (Saikō Saiban-sho, 最高裁判所, 1947–)
Details
Japanese District Court (Chihō Saiban-sho, 地方裁判所)
Details
Other Courts
Details
627–632
Index
627–632
Details
Durchsuchen Sie das Werk
Geben Sie ein Keyword in die Suchleiste ein
CC-BY-NC-ND
Access
A Comparative Study of the Formation of Contracts in Japanese, English, and German Law , page 1 - 28
Titelei/Inhaltsverzeichnis
Autoren
Anna Katharina Suzuki-Klasen
DOI
doi.org/10.5771/9783748911777-1
ISBN print: 978-3-8487-7128-8
ISBN online: 978-3-7489-1177-7
Chapter Preview
Chapter Preview
Share
Download PDF
Download citation
RIS
BibTeX
Copy DOI link
doi.org/10.5771/9783748911777-1
Share by email
Video schließen
Share by email Nomos eLibrary
Recipient*
Sender*
Message*
Your name
Send message
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy
and
Terms of Service
apply.
