The Theories of Constituição Dirigente and Transformative Constitutionalism and Their Reception by Brazilian Constitutional Theory: An Approach Based on Critical Comparative Law - Nomos eLibrary

VRÜ Verfassung und Recht in Übersee / The Theories of Constituição Dirigente and Transformative Constitutionalism and Their Reception by Brazilian Constitutional Theory: An Approach Based on Critical Comparative Law

VRÜ Verfassung und Recht in Übersee / The Theories of Constituição Dirigente and Transformative Constitutionalism and Their Reception by Brazilian Constitutional Theory: An Approach Based on Critical Comparative Law

Contents
- Chapter Expand | CollapseAuthorsPage
- 491–492 Titelei/Inhaltsverzeichnis 491–492
- 493–610 Symposium 493–610
  - 493–505 The Directive Constitution in the Varieties of Constitutionalism: An Introduction Michael Riegner Michael Riegner 493–505
  - 506–523 "Constitucionalismo Dirigente" and Transformative Constitutionalism: Common Elements, Differences, and Methodological Challenges Mariana Canotilho Mariana Canotilho 506–523
  - 524–548 Asking for Directions: The Origins of Gomes Canotilho Directive Constitutionalism at the Crossroads of Contemporary Constitutional Thought Luís António Malheiro Meneses do Vale Luís António Malheiro Meneses do Vale 524–548
  - 549–567 Transformation by Decree? A (Brief) Reflection on the ‘Directive Constitution’ (Constituição Dirigente) in Brazil Florian F. Hoffmann, Fabio Carvalho Leite Florian F. Hoffmann, Fabio Carvalho Leite 549–567
  - 568–586 The Theories of Constituição Dirigente and Transformative Constitutionalism and Their Reception by Brazilian Constitutional Theory: An Approach Based on Critical Comparative Law Deo Campos Dutra Deo Campos Dutra 568–586
  - 587–601 Bridging Past and Future: Transformative Constitutionalism and Directive Constitutions Amidst Authoritarian Challenges Juliana Cesario Alvim Gomes Juliana Cesario Alvim Gomes 587–601
  - 602–610 A Comment from a South African Perspective on Directive and Transformative Constitutionalism in Comparative Constitutional Law Jonathan Klaaren Jonathan Klaaren 602–610
- 611–654 Abhandlungen / Articles 611–654
  - 611–632 State of Exception and Internal Colonialism:The Construction of the Belo Monte Power Plant in Brazil Giovanni Martins de Araújo Mascarenhas Giovanni Martins de Araújo Mascarenhas 611–632
  - 633–654 Lessons from the Law and Politics of Federalism in Africa: Federalism Is Bigger Than Federation; Constitutions Are More Than Single Mega-Documents; the International Trumps the Domestic; and the Past Continues to Matter Jan Erk Jan Erk 633–654
- 655–662 Buchbesprechungen / Book Reviews 655–662
  - 655–659 Arun K Thiruvengadam, Constitution of India: A Contextual Analysis Florian Matthey-Prakash Florian Matthey-Prakash 655–659
  - 659–662 Silvia von Steinsdorff, Ece Göztepe, Maria Abad Andrade and Felix Petersen, The Constitutional Court of Turkey Between Legal and Political Reasoning İlker Gökhan Sen İlker Gökhan Sen 659–662
- 663–663 VRÜ/WCL Article Prize Volume 54 (2021) 663–663
- 664–664 Call for Papers 664–664
- 665–666 Impressum 665–666
Durchsuchen Sie das Werk
Geben Sie ein Keyword in die Suchleiste ein
CC-BY Access

VRÜ Verfassung und Recht in Übersee , page 568 - 586

The Theories of Constituição Dirigente and Transformative Constitutionalism and Their Reception by Brazilian Constitutional Theory: An Approach Based on Critical Comparative Law

Autoren

Deo Campos Dutra

DOI
- doi.org/10.5771/0506-7286-2023-3-568
- ISSN: 0506-7286
- ISSN online: 2941-9603
Abstract

Two of the most important constitutional theories developed in contemporary times, transformative constitutionalism and the idea of “Constituição Dirigente”, significantly impacted the Brazilian constitutional debate. Both are recurrent objects of reflection and influence how Brazilian constitutionalists formulate their thinking regarding their constitution. On the other hand, this evident case of legal transfer has rarely been analyzed from the perspective of legal comparison theory. The question this research intends to answer is to what extent these legal ideas were incorporated, considering the complexity of integrating foreign legal concepts. Our initial hypothesis centers on the argument that, despite important exceptions, most of the Brazilian doctrine received both theories in an objectified and recontextualized way, leading to an uncritical reflection and, sometimes, epistemologically colonized doctrine.
Share