Naturaleza, ecosistemas y acceso a la justicia: Estudio del caso Bosque de Hambach - Alemania

María José Narváez Alvarez

doi:10.5771/0506-7286-2021-3-352

Inhalt
- Kapitel Ausklappen | EinklappenAutorenSeiten
- 321–322 Titelei/Inhaltsverzeichnis 321–322
- 323–330 Editorial 323–330
  - Nature’s Day in Court. Rights of Nature and Access to Justice in Ecuador and Germany Andreas Fischer-Lescano, Andreas Gutmann Andreas Fischer-Lescano, Andreas Gutmann
- 331–439 Abhandlungen / Articles 331–439
  - 331–351 Should the Absentees Have Standing? The Fundamentals that Justify Nature Accessing Justice in Germany and Ecuador Andreas Gutmann, Viviana Morales Naranjo Andreas Gutmann, Viviana Morales Naranjo 331–351
  - 352–375 Naturaleza, ecosistemas y acceso a la justicia: Estudio del caso Bosque de Hambach - Alemania María José Narváez Alvarez María José Narváez Alvarez 352–375
  - 376–397 Invisibilising Nature. Procedural Limits and Possibilities to Environmental Litigation in German Law Elena Sofia Ewering, Tore Vetter Elena Sofia Ewering, Tore Vetter 376–397
  - 398–414 Access to Justice through Environmental Public Interest Litigation: Exploring Contemporary Trends in Nigeria Emeka Polycarp Amechi, Uzuazo Etemire, Agent Ihua-Maduenyi Emeka Polycarp Amechi, Uzuazo Etemire, Agent Ihua-Maduenyi 398–414
  - 415–439 The Southern Turn in Comparative (Constitutional) Law. Review Essay: The Global South and Comparative Constitutional Law Daniel Bonilla Maldonado Daniel Bonilla Maldonado 415–439
- 440–449 Buchbesprechungen / Book Reviews 440–449
  - 440–444 Andreas Gutmann, Hybride Rechtssubjektivität – Die Rechte der „Natur oder Pacha Mama“ in der ecuadorianischen Verfassung von 2008, Contributions on Comparative Public Law and International Law, Vol. 307, Nomos, Baden-Baden 2021, 309 pages, Hardcover, 89.00 Euro, ISBN 9783848782451 Jasper Mührel Jasper Mührel 440–444
  - 445–449 Kevin E. Davis, Between Impunity and Imperialism: The Regulation of Transnational Bribery, Oxford University Press, New York 2019, 332 pages, 61.00 GBP, ISBN 9780190070809 Mariana Mota Prado, Mariana Mota Prado, 445–449
- 450–457 Bibliographie / Bibliography 450–457
  - 450–450 RECHT UND ENTWICKLUNG ALLGEMEIN / LAW AND DEVELOPMENT IN GENERAL 450–450
  - 450–452 AFRIKA / AFRICA 450–452
  - 452–455 ASIEN / ASIA 452–455
  - 455–456 LATEINAMERIKA / LATIN AMERICA 455–456
  - 456–457 NAHER UND MITTLERER OSTEN / NEAR AND MIDDLE EAST 456–457
- 458–458 Call for Papers 458–458
- 459–459 Impressum 459–459
Durchsuchen Sie das Werk
Geben Sie ein Keyword in die Suchleiste ein
Vollzugriff

VRÜ Verfassung und Recht in Übersee , Seite 352 - 375

Naturaleza, ecosistemas y acceso a la justicia: Estudio del caso Bosque de Hambach - Alemania

Autoren

María José Narváez Alvarez

DOI
- doi.org/10.5771/0506-7286-2021-3-352
- ISSN print: 0506-7286
- ISSN online: 2941-9603
Zusammenfassung

La autora propone un ejercicio metodológico de transferencia de conceptos, normas y principios creados en el sistema jurídico ecuatoriano - que reconoce a la Naturaleza como sujeto de Derechos, y del derecho a acceder a la justicia en particular - a los hechos que ameritaron la expedición de la sentencia No. 14 K 4496/18, expedida por el Tribunal Administrativo de Colonia - Alemania el 12 de marzo de 2019, a propósito de la acción presentada por la ONG BUND NRW eV en contra del Gobierno Distrital de Arnsberg, por la cesión forzosa de un terreno de su propiedad ubicado en el bosque de Hambach, dentro del área minera concesionada a la compañía RWE Power AG para la extracción de lignito, en la cual el juzgador resuelve a favor de la empresa minera. La autora busca perfilar criterios de análisis que habrían derivado en una sentencia favorable para la vigencia de los Derechos de la Naturaleza si el caso hubiera sido resuelto en jurisdicción ecuatoriana.

Abstract

The author proposes a methodological exercise of transfer of concepts, norms and principles created in the Ecuadorian legal system - which recognizes Nature as a subject of Rights, and of the right to access justice in particular - to the facts that merited the issuance of judgment No. 14 K 4496/18, issued by the Administrative Court of Cologne - Germany on March 12, 2019, regarding the action filed by the NGO BUND NRW eV against the District Government of Arnsberg, for the forced transfer of a piece of land of his property located in the Hambach forest, within the mining area concessioned to the company RWE Power AG for the extraction of lignite, in which the judge decides in favor of the mining company. The author seeks to outline analytical criteria that would have resulted in a favorable ruling for the validity of the Rights of Nature if the case had been resolved in Ecuadorian jurisdiction.
Teilen