Uzbekistan’s competition law and legal transplants

Mahsuda Tadjibayeva

doi:10.5771/0030-6444-2024-1-4

Contents
- Chapter Expand | CollapseAuthorsPage
- Titelei/Inhaltsverzeichnis
- 3–3 Editorial 3–3
- 4–100 AUFSÄTZE 4–100
  - 4–13 Uzbekistan’s competition law and legal transplants Mahsuda Tadjibayeva Mahsuda Tadjibayeva 4–13
  - 14–28 Uzbek LLCs as a Legal Transplant: Evolution, Challenges, and Future Reforms Utkirbek Kholmirzaev Utkirbek Kholmirzaev 14–28
  - 29–42 Constitutional Control Body of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Issues Regarding the Conception of Property, the Equality of State and Private Property Ermek B. Abdrasulov, Bagila T. Tleulesova Ermek B. Abdrasulov, Bagila T. Tleulesova 29–42
  - 43–48 Protection Mechanism of Constitutional Property Rights: Content in Kazakhstani Criminal Proceedings Nurgaliyeva Ajdana Bachytovna Nurgaliyeva Ajdana Bachytovna 43–48
  - 49–64 Intellectual Property Regimes in Central Asia: Assessing Innovation Performance, International Agreements, And WTO Participation Nargiza Ramazonova Nargiza Ramazonova 49–64
  - 65–72 Legal Regulation of Intangible Objects: Experience of the Kazakhstan Republic Aizhan Abdrasulova Aizhan Abdrasulova 65–72
  - 73–78 Problems of Combining Public and Private Interests in Kazakhstan Labour Legislation Nurgaliyeva Enlik Nurgalievna Nurgaliyeva Enlik Nurgalievna 73–78
  - 79–91 New era of administrative reforms in Central Asia – a brief overview Asal Juraeva Asal Juraeva 79–91
  - 92–100 Application of the principle of active role of courts in proving an administrative case in Kazakhstan Yerik Akhmetov, Bergengul Ahmet Yerik Akhmetov, Bergengul Ahmet 92–100
- 101–103 AUS DEM SCHRIFTTUM 101–103
- 104–106 AUS JUSTIZ UND RECHTSPRECHUNG IN OSTEUROPA 104–106
Durchsuchen Sie das Werk
Geben Sie ein Keyword in die Suchleiste ein
Access

OER Osteuropa Recht , page 4 - 13

Uzbekistan’s competition law and legal transplants

Autoren

Mahsuda Tadjibayeva

DOI
- doi.org/10.5771/0030-6444-2024-1-4
- ISSN: 0030-6444
- ISSN online: 2366-6730
Zusammenfassung

Die Globalisierung hat zu einem Ineinandergreifen der Rechtssysteme geführt und auch das usbekische Wettbewerbsrechts ist Ergebnis mehrerer größerer Rechtstransplantationen (Legal Transplants). Im usbekischen Recht zeigt sich einerseits die islamische Rechtstradition, die die rechtliche Regulierung der Wirtschaftsbeziehungen beeinflusst. Im Wettbewerbsrecht Usbekistans zeigen sich aber auch Einflüsse aus Russland, Belarus, der Ukraine und Kasachstan. Der Artikel untersucht das Wesen der Rechtstransplantation, ihre Bedeutung für die Entwicklung der Gesetzgebung, aber auch die teilweise Ineffizienz einer blinden Verdrängung älterer Rechtsnormen. Darüber hinaus werden die Entstehungsgeschichte des usbekischen Wettbewerbsrechts und die Prozesse der Umwandlung in ein hybrides Rechtssystem, das sich aus verschiedenen Elementen zusammensetzt, untersucht und Defizite bei der Umsetzung der Transplantation von Normen in das Wettbewerbsrechts analysiert.

Abstract

Globalization has led to the interaction of legal systems, and Uzbekistan's competition law system was formed as a result of several major legal transplants. In Uzbekistan, some of the Islamic legal traditions transplanted into the legal regulation of economic relations are even reflected in business practices. However, in the formation of competition legislation in Uzbekistan, there are also cases of legal transplants copied from donor countries as Russia, Belarus, Ukraine, and Kazakhstan. Although these donor countries have very similar legal systems, the effectiveness of legal transfer norms to Uzbekistan is low because of transplanting the concept entirely. Because the implementation of legal transplantation by blind copying may not always lead to effective results. Since the business legal system of Uzbekistan is mixed with the traditions of the Muslim society, it is necessary to adapt the legal ideas and principles of the donor countries to the business practices of the Uzbek society in the implementation of legal transplantation in competition law.

The article explores the essence of legal transplantation, its importance in the development of legislation, methods of applying legal transplantation, the inefficiency of blind displacement of the norms of law, the importance of adapting the legal ideas and principles of donor countries to the legal traditions and business practices of Uzbek society.

In addition, the history of the formation of the competition legal system of Uzbekistan and the processes of transformation into a hybrid legal system made up of various elements are investigated and some shortcomings in the implementation of legal transplantation of competition law are analyzed.
Share